From Resignation to Redemption: The Library Trustees' Thankless Job

In a move that surprised absolutely no one familiar with his history, Washoe County Library Director Jeff Scott resigned moments before his potential termination—repeating his 2015 Berkeley playbook when faced with similar circumstances. Now, as predictable as the sunrise, those who haven't bothered to examine his performance record are rallying with cries of impending book banning.

These accusations are being hurled at Library Board Chair Ann Silver, whose professional credentials as both Chamber of Commerce leader and attorney make book banning about as likely as finding unicorns in the reference section. Meanwhile, Washoe County Commissioner Mariluz Garcia has suddenly discovered a passion for library funding—conveniently omitting that her sister is a library employee who supported the now-departed director.

Let us all remember Commissioner Mariluz Garcia’s sister works for the library - she should have disclosed that in her social media post.

The true heroes in this saga are the library trustees who endured Jeff Scott's years of questionable management only to face public vilification for finally doing their jobs. Their performance review wasn't an act of censorship—it was the culmination of genuine concerns about leadership and accountability.

Before the pitchforks come out against those who dared question Scott's leadership, perhaps critics should consider what it takes to receive such a dismal performance review. The trustees deserve support for their courage, not condemnation for their oversight. And if nothing else, a thorough independent audit would reveal whether the trustees or the resigned director better served the public's interest in our treasured libraries.